Articles related to fourth amendment - Page 12 of 18

Hospitalization of DWI Suspect Does Not Create Per Se Exigency Justifying Warrantless Blood Draw (November 6, 2014)

The Chatham County sheriff’s deputy who arrested Ronald McCrary in Siler City for impaired driving at 7:34 p.m. on December 28, 2010 decided that if McCrary was taken to the hospital, he would obtain a sample of his blood without a warrant. McCrary was in fact taken to a nearby hospital—at his insistence—where he refused to cooperate with the medical staff and refused to consent to the withdrawal of his blood. Once the hospital discharged McCrary at 9:13 p.m., several officers restrained him while hospital staff withdrew his blood. Was the blood draw legal? 

READ POST "Hospitalization of DWI Suspect Does Not Create Per Se Exigency Justifying Warrantless Blood Draw (November 6, 2014)"

Warrantless Stops 101: Did a Seizure Occur? (October 13, 2014)

Sorting out Fourth Amendment issues in the context of warrantless stops can be tricky. I like to break the case down into five basic questions:

  1. Did a seizure occur?
  2. If so and it was a stop, was it supported by reasonable suspicion or other valid basis?
  3. If reasonable suspicion supported the stop, was the officer’s subsequent conduct sufficiently limited in scope?
  4. If the seizure was an arrest, was it supported by probable cause?
  5. If the arrest was supported by probable cause, was the search permissible

This flowchart illustrates the analysis:

READ POST "Warrantless Stops 101: Did a Seizure Occur? (October 13, 2014)"