Basics of International Extradition

Every now and then, someone asks me about international extradition. Usually it’s about Roman Polanski or some other bigwig charged in New York or California, but once in a while there’s a North Carolina connection, like “if Brad Cooper had fled to Canada, could he have been extradited back to stand trial?” Plus, it’s just a cool topic. So I thought I’d do a post about how it works, with the caveat right up front that this is on the fringes of my expertise.

“International extradition is the formal process by which a person found in one country is surrendered to another country for trial or punishment. The process is regulated by treaty and conducted between the Federal Government of the United States and the government of a foreign country.” United States Attorneys’ Manual § 9-15.000. Generally, extradition is possible only if the United States and the foreign country in question have an extradition treaty; a list of extradition treaties is available here. We have treaties with Canada and Mexico, and with most other nations that you could name in the next ten seconds; a list of nations with which we don’t have a treaty can be viewed here. Of some relevance in connection with the ongoing DSK case, the United States does have an extradition treaty with France . . . but it appears to exempt most French nationals, as discussed in this article.

Extradition is available only for certain offenses, though which offenses are extraditable depends on the country in question: “Extradition is generally limited to crimes identified in the treaty. Early treaties often recite a list of the specific extraditable crimes. . . . While many existing U.S. extradition treaties continue to list specific extraditable offenses, the more recent ones feature a dual criminality approach, and simply make all felonies extraditable.” Congressional Research Service, Extradition to and From the United States: Overview of the Law and Recent Treaties (Mar. 17, 2010). Sometimes questions arise regarding whether a particular crime (for example, PWISD cocaine) falls within a class of crimes set forth in a treaty (for example, “drug trafficking offenses”), and those questions can be difficult.

Anyhow, when a prosecutor believes that he or she is prosecuting an extraditable offense and wants to extradite a defendant from a foreign country, he or she should begin by contacting the Department of Justice’s Office of International Affairs. According to the Office’s website, it “coordinates the extradition or other legal rendition of international fugitives and all international evidence gathering.” The Office will assess the propriety of requesting extradition. If it sees fit, it will assist the prosecutor in preparing the required documents, and will then transmit the materials to the State Department with a recommendation that the foreign country be asked to extradite the person in question. “The Department of State will send the extradition documents and the translation to the American Embassy in the foreign country, which will present them under cover of a diplomatic note formally requesting extradition to the appropriate agency of the foreign government, usually the foreign ministry.” United States Attorneys’ Manual § 9-15.300. The relevant section of the State Department’s Foreign Affairs Manual is here.

There aren’t many substantive defenses to a proper extradition request, but there are a number of procedural hoops to jump through, with the exact procedures depending on the foreign country in question. Once the suspect has been determined to be extraditable — or has waived his right to contest extradition — the United States Marshals’ Service retrieves the suspect and brings him to court. United States Attorneys’ Manual § 9-15.300.

A good short overview of extradition is available here. A more detailed analysis by the Congressional Research Service is here. A guide to defending extradition requests is here. If any readers are extradition experts, feel free to chime in.

4 thoughts on “Basics of International Extradition”

  1. Avoid this “morass” if at all possible: I certainly am not an extradition expert, but I am an expert in avoiding hard research.

    1. Always check the citizenship of any defendant involved in any serious crime;

    2. I recently had luck increasing the bond of a Canadian citizen who commited a vehicular homicide (indicted for 2nd degree murder), from $150,000.00 which his parents posted the same day to $1,000,000.00, which will hold him, by informing the judge of the complexity and efficacy of the U.S.-Canadian extradition treaty. Thank God the guy showed up for his first appearance.
    Maybe a good practice is to educate your magistrates generally of the extradition process-might help to initially get higher bonds in an amount to hold the defendant until you can motion for a bond increase.

  2. Having recently been through this with the Cesar Laurean/Maria Lauterbach Homicide, have patience!!!! If your defendant is charged with a capital case and a Mexican National, and makes it back to Mexico, plan on giving up the death penalty before Mexican Authorities will even talk to you. State Department and Department of Justice (FBI) were a big help. it took about about 14 months to get Laurean back in the United States AFTER his capture in Mexico. I was told that this was expedited due to the International media coverage and America’s Most Wanted coverage. Prepare for a long waiting period!


Leave a Comment

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.